Flabbergasted former Wallabies captain and selector Andrew Slack can’t

fathom why Matt Giteau is set to be a controversial omission from

Australia’s World Cup squad.

Giteau was the Wallabies’

highest-paid player and star playmaker until last year but coach Robbie

Deans will controversially overlook the 28-year-old when he announces

his 30-man Cup squad on Thursday.

This is despite the 92-Test

stalwart being able to cover three positions, including halfback where

Deans is expected to include rookie Nick Phipps as a third specialist

No.9 behind general Will Genia and back-up Luke Burgess.


widespread understanding that NSW playmaker Berrick Barnes would pip

Giteau for the last backline place in the squad was confirmed on

Wednesday afternoon when the France-bound back posted a leading comment

on his Twitter account.

“Thank u ballboys, thank u linesman! That’s it”, Giteau tweeted.

He later confirmed his non-selection with another tweet.


wanna thank everyone for the support! Was a huge honour to get the

chance to represent my country as often as I did. veryprivileged”


means Deans has shown full faith in Barnes standing up as the only

specialist playmaker to back up incumbent Quade Cooper, just four club

matches back from the concussion problems which have clouded his career.


is highly regarded by Deans, who appointed him vice-captain ahead of

the 2009 spring tour before Barnes withdrew through injury.

Giteau was the man overlooked for the role at the time and his unhappiness showed.


reaction, as well as a failure to close out several close losses as

playmaker and goalkicker in 2009-10, seem to have cost him dearly.


Slack, who led Australia to their historic 1984 Grand Slam success in

the United Kingdom, didn’t see Giteau as out of form or a destabilising

influence, and deserved selection.

If there had been a genuine

fall-out between Deans and Giteau, the 39-Test centre said the pair

needed to man up and mend their bridges.

“From outside the team environment, I can’t see any reason why he wouldn’t be picked,” Slack told AAP.

“I know Giteau was close to being the Australian captain for the 2007 World Cup but it’s just got me flabbergasted.


only scuttlebutt/rumours but, if they don’t get on, one of them needs

to grow up, or both of them. If that is the issue, then that’s a real

shame because at the end of the day, the only people who end up paying

for that is everyone else.

“Talent, experience, class, versatility and healthy (match fit) – they’re five compelling factors I would have thought.”


is among six players with question marks over their fitness, and Slack

felt Giteau was a much safer bet as a back-up to X-factor Cooper.


other thing I think is the big seller is this third halfback; when you

pick a specialist third halfback (like Phipps) when you’ve got a Giteau

… is just crazy,” he said.

Giteau’s close friend Drew Mitchell –

who’d suffered an ankle injury during the Super Rugby season –

indicated through Twitter that he’d been selected but the winger was

feeling sorry for his mate.

“The song of the day is Bittersweet Symphony by The Verve,” he tweeted.


Tatafu Polota-Nau (knee), prop James Slipper (ankle) and centre Rob

Horne (elbow) are all expected to join Mitchell in the squad after

undergoing fitness testing on Wednesday but No.8 Wycliff Palu (shoulder)

is in doubt.

Reactivated Radike Samo may sneak in ahead of Palu while veteran lock Dan Vickerman is also crossing his fingers.